Ether and Modernity: The recalcitrance of an epistemic object in the early twentieth century

ISBN : 9780198797258

Jaume Navarro
272 ページ
168 x 240 mm

Ether and Modernity offers a snapshot of the status of an epistemic object, the "ether" (or "aether"), in the early twentieth century. The contributed papers show that the ether was often regarded as one of the objects of modernity, hand in hand with the electron, radioactivity or X-rays, and not simply as the stubborn residue of an old-fashioned, long-discarded science. The prestige and authority of scientists and popularisers like Oliver Lodge and Arthur Eddington in Britain, Phillip Lenard in Germany or Dayton C. Miller in the USA was instrumental in the preservation, defence or even re-emergence of the ether in the 1920s. Moreover, the consolidation of wireless communications and radio broadcasting, indeed a very modern technology, brought the ether into audiences that would otherwise never have heard about such an esoteric entity.

The ether also played a pivotal role among some artists in the early twentieth century: the values of modernism found in the complexities and contradictions of modern physics, such as wireless action or wave-particle puzzles, a fertile ground for the development of new artistic languages; in literature as much as in the pictorial and performing arts. Essays on the intellectual foundations of Umberto Boccioni's art, the linguistic techniques of Lodge, and Ernst Mach's considerations on aesthetics and physics witness to the imbricate relationship between the ether and modernism. Last but not least, the ether played a fundamental part in the resurgence of modern spiritualism in the aftermath of the Great War.

This book examines the complex array of meanings, strategies and milieus that enabled the ether to remain an active part in scientific and cultural debates well into the 1930s, but not beyond. This portrait may be easily regarded as the swan song of an epistemic object that was soon to fade away as shown by Paul Dirac's unsuccessful attempt to resuscitate some kind of aether in 1951, with which this book finishes.


1 Imogen Clarke: The ether at the crossroads of classical and modern physics
2 Connemara Doran: Lorentz's ether, Poincare's amorphous continuum, and Einstein's rejected-redefined 'ether' spacetime: Einstein's revolutionary physical universe in a revolutionizing mathematical world
3 Roberto Lalli: Hunting for the luminiferous ether: The revival of the Michelson-Morley experiment in the 1920s
4 Jaume Navarro: Ether and wireless: An old medium into new media
5 Scott Walter: Electron theory, the ether, and wireless technology, 1906-1929
6 Richard Staley: Ether and aesthetis in the dialogue between relativists and critics
7 Linda Dalrymple Henderson: Italian futurism and the ether: Umberto Boccioni's elasticity and unique forms of continuity in space
8 Michael Whitworth: Transformations of knowledge in Oliver Lodge's Ether and Reality
9 Richard Noakes: Making space for the soul: the psychic functions of Oliver Lodge's ether
10 Arne Schirrmacher: Ether and politics: Philipp Lenard's ether and German physics


Jaume Navarro is Ikerbasque Research Professor at the University of the Basque Country. Trained in Physics and in Philosophy he has developed a career in the History of Science in institutions like the University of Cambridge and the Max Planck Institute for the History of Science. He has written numerous research articles in the history of late-nineteenth- and early-twentieth physics.