Between Samaritans and States: The Political Ethics of Humanitarian Ingos

ISBN : 9780198778691

Jennifer Rubenstein
272 ページ
156 x 234 mm

This book provides the first book-length, English-language account of the political ethics of large-scale, Western-based humanitarian INGOs, such as Oxfam, CARE, and Doctors Without Borders. These INGOs are often either celebrated as 'do-gooding machines' or maligned as incompetents 'on the road to hell'. In contrast, this book suggests the picture is more complicated. Drawing on political theory, philosophy, and ethics, along with original fieldwork, this book shows that while humanitarian INGOs are often perceived as non-governmental and apolitical, they are in fact sometimes somewhat governmental, highly political, and often 'second-best' actors. As a result, they face four central ethical predicaments: the problem of spattered hands, the quandary of the second-best, the cost-effectiveness conundrum, and the moral motivation trade-off. This book considers what it would look like for INGOs to navigate these predicaments in ways that are as consistent as possible with democratic, egalitarian, humanitarian and justice-based norms. It argues that humanitarian INGOs must regularly make deep moral compromises. In choosing which compromises to make, they should focus primarily on their overall consequences, as opposed to their intentions or the intrinsic value of their activities. But they should interpret consequences expansively, and not limit themselves to those that are amenable to precise cost-benefit analysis. The book concludes by explaining the implications of its 'map' of humanitarian INGO political ethics for individual donors to INGOs, and for how we all should conceive of INGOs' role in addressing pressing global problems.


1 Introduction
2 Eight Extant Alternative Approaches
3 A Map of Humanitarian INGO Political Ethics
4 The Problem of Spattered Hands
5 The Quandary of the Second-best
6 The Cost-Effectiveness Conundrum
7 The Moral Motivation Tradeoff
8 Conclusion: Political Political Ethics


Jennifer Rubenstein is an Assistant Professor of Politics at the University of Virginia, specializing in political theory.